|
Prozac (t.m.) and
similar drugs vs. a food nutrient for Depression, Bi-Polar & Panic
Disorders.
Which is better according to Medical Science?
"Only
70% of patients respond to current treatments for panic disorder, and many
discontinue drugs because of side effects. 'Inositol]...has previously
been found superior to placebo in the treatment of depression, panic
disorder, and obsessive-compulsive disorder."
The
medical scientists tested inositol against the drug Luvox (t.m.). Both
Prozac and Luvox are classed as SSRI*drugs. After administering inositol
to one group of patients and Luvox to the others for panic disorders, they
found that "...scores were similar for both treatments.
"In the
first month, inositol reduced the number of panic attacks per week by 4.0
compared with a reduction of 2.4 with fluvoxamine 'Luvox, t.m.]. Nausea
and tiredness were more common with fluxoxamine...Because inositol is a
natural compound with few known side effects, it is attractive to patients
who are ambivalent about taking psychiatric medication..." Footnote 1.
In
another test comparing inositol with placebo against bi-polar disease
(depression,) "...On the Montgomery-Asberg Depression Rating Scale, eight
(67%) of twelve inositol-treated subjects had a 50% or greater decrease in
'their depression scores] compared to four (33%) of twelve subjects
assigned to placebo.
"Inositol was well tolerated
with minimal side effects...The tolerability and the 'natural substance'
aspect of
inositol may be
particularly appealing to subjects with bipolar depression."
Emphasis added. Footnote 2.
"Inositol...was reported to have
therapeutic effects in depressive patients
and to be effective in two animal models of depression...
"Inositol countered the
exaggerated immobility of 'animals] in the forced swim test, without
affecting control
animals. Data support our
previous suggestion of inositol as a potential antidepressant." Emphasis
added. Footnote 3.
The (t.m.)
indications above refer to trade mark.
*Selective Serotonin Re-uptake inhibitors.
1.
Journal of Psychopharmacology, vol. 21, 2001, Ben Gurian U. of Negev,
Isreal.
2. Bipolar Disorders, vol. 2, 2000, U. of Pitts. School of Medicine, Pa.
3. Depression & Anxiety, vol. 15, Ben Gurian U., Isreal.
Other
references were omitted for brevity, but they included studies from World
Journal of Biological Psychiatry & Archives of Internal Medicine, vol.
164, 2004, the latter of which concluded, "A substantial number of
adequately treated patients did not respond to antidepressant 'drugs.]"
Soybeans anyone?
MORE ON
DEPRESSION
back
to Women's Health index

TOP OF PAGE
SEARCH BY SUBJECT -
TABLE OF CONTENTS
THIS MONTH'S HEALTH
BULLETIN NEWS

If you
find Health Bulletin
interesting,
please click here to "Tell a Friend"


click here |